Empowering frontline leaders amid Trump’s massive global aid cuts, with War Child’s Dr. Samantha Nutt

Transcript from https://podmenti.com/t/6306dece3eda4bb3

The very best founders I know are brilliant at building systems.
They connect teams, they remove bottlenecks, and they eliminate single points of failure. And yet
When it comes to their own wealth.
Most are running a disconnected stack.
A tax accountant here and a state attorney there, a wealth manager who doesn't talk to either one of them.
Creative planning was built to fix exactly that.
One integrated team of tax professionals, state planners, investment specialists, all coordinated by a dedicated wealth manager who sees your full financial picture and keeps every piece working together.
Proactive tax efficiency, state strategy, investments all under one roof.
Creative planning where wealth works together.
Learn more at creative planning dot com slash masters of scale.
Hey folks, Jeff Berman here. I am thrilled to share some of the new names who will be joining us at this year's Masters of Scale summit.
This may be our biggest stage yet.
Reed Hastings, Meredith Whitaker, Van Jones, Amjad Masad, and more.
Will be there with us October 20th through 22nd in San Francisco. If you're building something great, or you want to build something great,
We want you there with us too.
Join us at masters of scale dot com slash apply twenty six.
That's mastersofscom slash apply.
Twenty six.
When we saw what happened with the Taliban in Afghanistan and the fall of Kabul, we were already operational in nine different districts. Most of those were already under de facto Taliban control. We did have a period of time where our operations were suspended in Kabul, but then we were able to resume our activities, including our women and girls education and economic development work.
Sometimes you have to hold your nose.
And you have to
be diplomatic and you have to negotiate with people that you fundamentally disagree with. Nothing
will ever change.
If we just allow
The present

Erase the progress of the past.
That's Samantha Nutt.
Президента Ворчалд Усе і Ворчалд Канада.
When I first learned about War Child, I was blown away by the impact Sam and her group have had on at-risk children in some of the world's worst conflict zones. With the US is spending billions in humanitarian aid, I wanted to ask Sam about the real world impacts. Her perspective is bracing, illuminating, and inspiring.
And her enthusiasm about the generosity of Americans as separate from the US government is unexpected. So let's get to it.
I'm Bob Safian and this
his rapid response
I'm Bob Safian. I'm here with Dr. Samantha Nutt, founder and president of War Child USA and War Child Canada. Uh, Sam, great to chat with you. Thanks for being here. Well, thank you for having me, Bob. So Warchild helps.
Children and families in communities impacted by armed conflict all around the world. Can you can you give us a s a practical sense of what that entails?
We are the bridge between emergency humanitarian assistance and then the things that children and their families need to
actually rebuild and recover in war zones. So a lot of groups are doing really important emergency work, food, water, shelter, and blankets, but they aren't thinking about the long term. What do kids and their families need to be able to recover from war, to become more resilient, to foster peace within their communities. And so that is what we do. So for example in Sudan,
For many years we've been on the ground since the early two thousands. I've been there many times. Uh we were doing catch up learning programming. So for people who had been displaced as a result of the conflict within the country, many millions of them, it's gotten a lot worse. We'll talk about that probably a bit later, but many millions of them were living in camps for internally displaced people. And then those
So they were out of school and they were falling further and further behind and they had fewer options. And so we were running catch up learning programs that we developed that we're known for throughout the world.
To allow children to catch up on their education, to reintegrate back into the appropriate grade level, to complete their studies and then to provide for themselves. If you don't do those kinds of things and kids continue to fall further behind, they're more easily recruited, they're more vulnerable, their families are more vulnerable, and then that cycle of of poverty just becomes more and more entrenched. I mean you
You served as a doctor helping
children and families affected by war before you started War Child.
And you chose to focus this organization.
on education and job opportunities
Which focus on sort of the fallout after conflict. Cause like the attention sort of drops away at that point.
War isn't a short term issue, right? So you don't have a situation where war goes on for a few months and then suddenly goes away. That never happens. It goes on for years and years and years, and the effects of war are felt for generations. And I did start right out of medical school. I was recruited by UNICEF to work in Somalia during the famine in the early nineties.
When the next crisis hit, when Rwanda hit, all of that capacity packed up and moved to the next crisis and l left communities completely dependent and completely decimated. And then what happened as a result of that is that violence started to resurface. And so unless you address the drivers of war, and the drivers of war are things like poverty.
instability, the lack of of rights and opportunities for women and girls, especially keeping young boys out of the militia groups through education, through skills training, through economic development, you're going to face a situation where countries are locked in conflict, they are locked in crisis and they become more and more vulnerable.
And more dependent on humanitarian aid. And the reality is it will never be enough. And we're seeing that play out in the world right now. We're seeing
An explosion in the number of crises that the world is facing. We're seeing the w withdrawal of the US in particular, the withdrawal of USAID. So less money that's available to address these crises right as they become more critical.
And millions of people are at risk. You work a lot through local organizations. You mentioned sort of finding local folks who ca who can do things. That's not what a lot of NGOs do. It's not what UNICEF does.
It also means the work gets really dispersed, though, right? Like communicating and coordinating among all that must be complicated.
It can be, but it doesn't have to be. I mean we for example, we have more than a thousand staff throughout the world. Ninety nine point nine percent of them are local to the countries in which we are operating, including at the most senior level, the country director level. And
It takes us time to be operational. We're not an organization that you'll see, you know, a headline in the news that says this is terrible, this is happening in this place, and we'll say, Well, we're there and please give to us now. That's not how we operate. Sometimes it will take us a couple of years to identify our staff, identify our partners, to build up that capacity to
develop our strategies in conjunction with other organizations that are on the ground because we don't want to duplicate services. I mean w when we saw what happened with the Taliban in Afghanistan and the fall of Kabul, we were already operational in nine different districts. Most of those were already under de facto Taliban control.
We did have a period of time where our operations were suspended in Kabul, but then we were able to resume our activities, including our women and girls education and economic development work that we've been doing for more than twenty years. And we could do that because we were locally driven, locally accepted, and widely respected. And that I think is a a
an important point of distinction for the kind of work that we do in our and no no conflict with the Taliban now as you're trying to I mean look, you know, these things are never easy, right? I mean I've been I've been doing this work for
thirty years and
Sometimes you have to hold your nose.
And you have to uh be diplomatic and you have to negotiate with people that you fundamentally disagree with, uh on on every conceivable level, especially for me as a woman. At the same time, we have a hundred and seventy staff in Afghanistan, all local.
Half of those staff are women.
And they are doing critical services to women and girls who in this moment in time, in this moment in history, would have nothing else. They would not they don't have the opportunity to go to school after grade six, they don't have the opportunity for higher education, they don't have the opportunity to get a job.
And so
If we're not careful and thoughtful.
About
how we interact with the Taliban and how we negotiate safe spaces for the women who depend on us and for our staff, then
Then we're out. And if we're out, that is absolutely devastating for hundreds of thousands of people, the vast majority of whom are women and girls.
You you alluded to this earlier, the the the Trump administration has stripped a ton of funding from humanitarian organizations. I'm curious
What that meant.
For you at at war child.
When you first heard about USAID funds being slashed, where where were you? And sort of what what was your reaction?
I was screaming at the television. Look, it's it's
It's devastating. It's absolutely devastating for the humanitarian movement.
Uh nothing like this has ever happened, certainly in the thirty years that I have been doing this kind of work. The US was the single largest contributor to uh foreign aid to humanitarian assistance in the world, over$9.5 billion. Now that represented it sounds like a giant number, but it represented a very
minuscule
amount of the US budget. It was less than one percent of the US budget every year, but it kept millions and millions and millions of people alive. We have more than thirty million people in the world who are food insecure. You have children, millions of children who are at risk of acute starvation within the next few months.
And the US was one of the major contributors, for example, to the World Food Program, to providing that kind of food security work. And that was just one example of what they did. So for us, even though we
may not have been very directly impacted. So you you're not you're not a a beneficiary of USAID fund. We have been we certainly have been uh over the years, but we were very fortunate in the sense that we didn't have any active contracts. However, because we work in partnership with so many organizations
It has affected us. So the UNFPA was one of our partners for Afghanistan. We're doing the direct implementation of that work. We lost about a million dollars in granting because the UNFPA lost a million dollars in granting as a result of USAID withdrawal. And that will that has resulted in our us having to close one of our children and youth centers.
And that affects tens of thousands of kids. Uh at the same time, we're in South Sudan, very food insecure, very
a very insecure country in general, you can't drive from one location in South Sudan to the other. There are not passable roads, it's too insecure. You have to rely on UN humanitarian flights that are run by the World Food Program.
Those flights used to be a few hundred dollars. Now they can't afford to run those flights. And so that means that we no longer have access to.
Keep
Populations that are in desperate need. And this is an example. I mean, we're we're one organization, but we are seeing the layoff of thousands upon thousands of people who had tremendous expertise, credibility, who were doing life-saving work throughout the world. And
And that is all evaporating. And there is no question that the US withdrawal and USAID's contraction will result in greater chaos and greater instability, and that will ultimately harm the US interest in the long run. So I I I want to pose something there. There's been this trope uh no one has died from
The US Secretary of State, Mario Rubio, right? Referring to the aid cuts. Now
Other folks claim hundreds of thousands, even millions of lives are are at stake. Can can you clarify
What the
differences what like what are the different folks talking about
Look, I think you can hide behind uh the lack of of of direct accountability, right? It is it is never the case that you're
you cut off USAID and you can draw a direct line between, well, this person died as a result of that. But what you do know is that when you start pulling on the thread of a sweater, what that's going to look like. And for example, in Sudan, you have the worst
displacement crisis more than ten million people displaced within Sudan um
And when you have the world's biggest funder saying, Well, we're not gonna provide food security, there's no question that there those people are that they're going to die. And
You know, while you can hide behind the the the veil of of a lack of direct accountability, the fallout is
It is clear, it is apparent, it is unignorable to anyone who has ever been on the ground in any of these situations. And we can see it coming at us like a freight train while we're standing there just twiddling our thumbs.

You know, you've been you've been trying to help
Kids at Warchild for a long time now.
You have a lot of passion about it.
frustrated sometimes that
that the world doesn't seem to learn the the reality of the of the work and the need that that you're addressing. What do you do with that?
It's hard and
you know that there are moments when, yeah, you you are raging against the wind and it can be incredibly frustrating.
It's often not the things that you would imagine that are frustrating. You expect governments to
to fail. You expect donors to change priorities. You expect people to
not necessarily have a high level of literacy or experience around what actually works when it comes to this this kind of uh humanitarian assistance. We often reward the wrong things at the expense of the right ones. We feel good
donating and getting a chic or a goat to somebody, but you know, that's not gonna change the world. Getting a kid into school that's been out of school for more than ten more than ten years, that's changing that kid's life and that's changing their community's life. And what frustrates me and what
enrages me all the time is that you see those gains, you can prove that it works. You're you you have all of these people who
Who
Believe in it.
And who demonstrate that it's possible.
And then, you know, you've got people who go, Well
Why should I care about kids in Africa?
And that's the stuff that um
Makes me drink bourbon. Not too much. I I I remember having a uh having a conversation with Jose Andres of the founder of World Central Kitchen, who who talked about how, you know, when he's in a crisis, he's so conscious of the impact he's having on people's lives. And then when he goes back home and
He's in a nice place and he's taking a shower or making a meal and he's got hot water.
And sometimes it it makes him feel guilty. Like he's not really sure how to manage those emotions on on both sides. And I and I wonder how you manage it.
There have certainly been especially when I was younger, there were moments when I was
Absolutely a self-righteous pain in the ass. Some people will tell you I still am. It's not a problem that we can enjoy.
food security and a great glass of wine and a wonderful night out and see a Broadway show and do all of those things. What's the problem is that so many millions of people can't enjoy that because they're falling asleep every night while guns are are are are firing and bombs are dropping. That's a problem. So I'm not interested in
Shaming anyone for doing anything. What I would like them to do.
Oh I mean look, I I
I carry a lot of grief and a lot of guilt, but it's not
What you would expect. It's because I've lost
so many friends doing this work.
Um
And why am I here and they're not here?
And so I
I don't
rail against what we have here, I find it
That this is my moment to
To just stabilize and to get back to what I need to be doing, which is to raise money to make that stuff happen and to build good programs and to be um you know to build a stronger organization. And when and when a new
conflict, you know, breaks out somewhere in the world. Like, how do you decide whether to jump in?
You know, uh'cause even if you have resources, you could
double down on someplace else you already are. Like how do you how do you make those judgments?
We are obviously under a tremendous amount of pressure to be everywhere all at once, and you can spread yourself too thin. We will look at it from a number of different perspectives. The first one is do we have expertise in the region that would
be added value in this context, or are there other organizations that are already doing a fantastic job? Secondly, if it's in the middle of a very acute crisis, we are not Doctors Without Borders. We are not the Red Cross. We do not have that level of infrastructure to be running food aid in that is not what we do. We are a long term recovery and rehabilitation organization
organization. So we require a level of cooperation and local engagement for that to happen. And that's very difficult to do while bombs are dropping. The third piece of what we will look at is what is the relationship with whether it's the local government or local militia groups or whoever it is that you have to deal with. And can we operate
um safely and with a degree of autonomy and with the degree of accountability that we require. We won't work in an area where we think that our resources are going to be redirected by
terrorist organizations, or we risk being infiltrated by terrorist organizations. So we will not commit to something if we don't believe that we can meet our standards. That, for example, is one of the reasons why we're not in Somalia right now. Um and there are other examples of that. So it's a bunch of things.
Sam is an intriguing mix of both extreme discipline as a leader and full-on passion. So, how is she harnessing that right now to propel Warchild in this time of turmoil? We'll talk about that and more after the break. Stay with us.
Hey listeners, Bob here. If you listen to Rapid Response on Masters of Scale, you may be missing half the show.
Because every Friday we release a second rapid response exclusively in the Rapid Response feed. The guests and topics are just as compelling and timely from Ford CEO to NASA's administrator to the lessons from The Devil Wears Prada.
It takes about 10 seconds to find, just search rapid response wherever you listen to podcasts and hit follow to make sure you never miss an episode.
I hope to see you there.
Oh
Humans will never be more intelligent than AI.
There's gonna be two types of companies.
Those were great at AI and those that went out of business because they weren't. How do we build a future?
That is human centered.
I'm Rana El Chaoyubi.
On my podcast Pioneers of AI, we answer that question and so many more. As an AI scientist, entrepreneur, and investor, I know what it takes to build AI that works for everyone.
Every week, I sit down with the pioneers shaping our future. And we take you behind the scenes of the AI that's transforming our lives.
Find pioneers of AI wherever you tune in.
Mm-hmm.
Before the break, war child Samantha Nutt talked about the rising perils for children and families in conflict zones. Now she explains how humanitarian aid can be most efficiently deployed and how the generosity of Americans for those in need overseas contrasts with recent pullbacks by the US government.
Plus a personal story about two young women in Darfur that will tug at your heartstrings.
Let's jump back in.
War child USA and War Child Canada are part of a wider war child.
Federation. Each unit is
Pretty independent as I understand it. Why why not why not band together more?
Like w wouldn't that help fundraising and efficiency and impact and all that? And we do. We do. So as a loose federation, we will um collaborate and cooperate and and it
to the extent that our we're operating in the same parts of the world, then they will they will work together, our field teams. The reality is that um the European arm tends to do a lot more advocacy. We are much
more of the f direct boots on the ground field organization. So when we say we have programs in Afghanistan, those are our programs in Afghanistan. If people want to give to our organization, we know exactly where all of those dollars are going and to whom and for what purpose and what the outcome should be. What we have seen in other places is that
You know, you donate to one organization, they take an administrative overhead, then it gets transferred to their headquarters in Geneva, and then they take administrative overhead, and then it gets to the field level and they take administrative overhead and then they subcontract it out.
To us because we're the direct field organization, and those those dollars become pennies pretty fast, and that's not how we want to operate.
There's so much
chaotic in our world right now.
How would you advise others who feel a little bit overwhelmed by what's going on and maybe
Sort of
Sometimes turn off themselves?
The worst thing you can do is to is to shut yourself off from the world because it will only make those problems exponentially worse. When you start having the conversation and you start to
I understand that there are ways that you can
be incredibly effective. It doesn't take a lot of money to radically transform whether it's a child's life or a family's life or a woman's life or a community's life in some of the most vulnerable places on earth. The the amazing thing to me
about the United States is that there isn't usually an expectation that government will do things for you. Um there are other parts of the world where people don't give because they're like, well, yeah, wow, that's what my tax dollars go to pay for, right? Americans are
extremely generous. And I I do think that for people who look at the collapse of USAID and think that doesn't serve American interests throughout the world, that that
Actually makes us more vulnerable to a whole bunch of different things. Um, whether that's acts of aggression or acts of terrorism, or just declining US influence in the world, which has massive implications, not just economic implications, but other implications as well.
I think that there are
good people who then go, Well if government's not gonna do that for us
We're gonna step in and we're gonna do that.
And you can feel like it's a drop in the ocean, but when there are enough people doing this kind of thing, you can have a significant influence. And and that's really important.
But ultimately
you're still moving along that path.
It it it sounds like right now when the the funding situation is so difficult, when organizations like Warchild are being asked to sort of step up and do more. What do you feel like is at stake right now?
For for you, for Warchild, for for for all of us.
The world is in a very unstable state.
Place.
And I don't think that that is a a shocking statement or a surprising statement for many. We are seeing
More violence, more conflict, more instability, more food insecurity. We are witnessing the worst displacement crisis since World War Two, with over a hundred and seventeen million people forced from their homes. All of that instability
creates global pressures. It it

It impacts us here at home in a number of ways, whether you're talking about migration, whether you're talking about disruptions to trade routes, for example, with with the war in Yemen through the Red Sea, which is thirty percent of the world's shipping containers go through the Red Sea there. And then you go and you're trying to
buy groceries and other things, and you're wondering why they're so much more expensive than they were a couple of years ago. Uh everything is interconnected and and interrelated in that fashion. And
For
Us as an organization, we have been fortunate that
Despite
Or maybe because of.
What we are witnessing that we have had
Great.
partnerships with foundations, uh, with corporate partners, with other government funders, the Canadian government and others who are are trying to step up. It will never
Replace the void.
of the of USAID's withdrawal. Never, never.
Um
But hopefully that's not permanent either. The one thing that war teaches you is that um
Nothing is permanent.
Everything that we have.
can change for better or for worse
And w if we want to build strong, democratic and inclusive societies, we have to
Invest in that.
We have to
Maintain that.
And we have to fund that.
Mm.
For uh for folks who are listening to this.
As individuals, as organizations, if they wanna
Uh, support the work War Child is doing. What what can they do?
Well, they can call us and we'll have a conversation. But our our the website is awardshellusa.org and then they can also contact us through our various social media channels. If you have skills or expertise or you just want to learn more, please don't hesitate to reach out because we would welcome the opportunity.
Yeah.
I I w one one last question. Is there a story of any
particular individual or family.
That sticks with you, that sort of
Fuels you that you
Go back to
I'll give you the example of of of Darfur. Not too long ago I was at the uh
Border between South Sudan and Sudan, we had been on the ground in El Janina, which is in West Arfor, which was the epicenter of violence.
And when I say violence, I mean horrific genocidal atrocities. We had been running for um almost twenty years programming, educational programming for for kids.
Again, catch up learning.
And then we were running f women's literacy efforts. And so many years ago when we had first started, I was in
um one of those literacy centers.
And I was there and I struck up a conversation with a young woman, her name was Nadia, and she was sitting on this mat on the sand and she had her baby boy beside her and she'd been attending our women's literacy programming every every evening.
like seventy percent of women in Darfur, she was functionally illiterate prior to starting this.
She'd been in her village and she was forced to flee because her husband and her f her father and her mother were gunned down right in front of her.
Yeah.
And so there she was, um
on this particular evening and
And there are two parts to the story because
As I was talking to her, I was really struck by the enormity of the challenges that women like Nadia face.
And when she had arrived in this camp
Not only was she traumatized and alone, she
couldn't even take the few possessions that she had managed to scrounge and go into town and barter them for cash to buy supplies that she and her child needed because she couldn't do the simplest mathematical equations.
And so when that
Uh, when I was talking to her in this particular evening, as I left, I said to her, You know, Nadia, has anything that we have done here actually helped you?

And then she was sitting on this mat.
um on the sand and uh
It was very powerful. The first thing she did was she just leaned forward and she wrote her name.
And then she said, Now that I know how to write my own name, I'm going to learn how to write my son's name.
And so there I was in
in South Sudan uh just a few months ago and
Visiting one of the Darfurian
makeshift refugee camps and our team pulls in.
And
We're there and it's all women and children, all of them. Many of them had seen
All the male family members gunned down.
before flee before fleeing. They were living in this burned
down makeshift mosque with no electricity, no plumbing, starving. And as soon as we pulled in, this young girl to the car.
And uh
And she immediately says to me, she says, I know, Warchild, I know Warchild. I was in your program, your education program in El Janina, which is the same place where I met Nadia.

And she said, and I did your catch up learning program and then I went and I went to school and I went to medical school. And she was very interested because I'm a doctor and so we started talking about that. And she had just finished her last exams.
But then the war broke out and she was forced to flee. Since she didn't know if her family members were still alive, she hadn't been able to reach them.

And as she's sitting there looking at our team, she said, um, the last thing she said that day was
I knew you wouldn't forget us.
I knew you would come.
And
That's what it's all about.
It is about
Бін презент і піп'я.
When they need you the most.
When the rest of the world has forgotten?
It is about being
Consistent.
Because nothing.
will ever change
If we just allow the present
Two
erase the progress of the past.
And I think that we are very much at risk of doing that right now. And if when that happens
we will all be living in a much more
Unstable.
and frightening world.
Well, Sam, this was great and thank you so much for doing it. I really appreciate it.
Well, thank you for having me.
Thank you.

Sam's Live Perspective on the ground in some of the most challenging places on earth gives her both clarity and perspective. It's a reminder to all of us that larger realities are sometimes overlooked, that our priorities can be clouded by narrowness, and that we too often fail to appreciate the advantages that we have.
Generosity isn't simplistic altruism. It's an act of empathy and an investment in problem solving.
That's something every business and each of us should be inspired to embrace.
А Боб Сафін
Thanks for listening.

Rapid response is a wait what original.
I'm Bob Safian. Our executive producer is Eve Tro. Our producer is Alex Morris. Associate producer is Mashimaku Tonina.
Mixing and Mastering by Aaron Bastonelli.
Our theme music is by Ryan Holiday.
Our head of podcasts is Le Tal Malad.
For more, visit rapidresponesshow.com.